Find your next step
Repair
Under 8 years old, and a single part failed: capacitor, contactor, fan motor or drain line.
Routine fixes on a system with plenty of life left.
Run the rule
8 to 12 years old, with a bigger repair quote: coil or refrigerant leak.
Use the $5,000 rule below and ask for both options in writing.
Consider replacing
Over 12 years old, needing a compressor or a second major repair in two years.
Replacement deserves a serious look.
Usually replace
Uses R-22 refrigerant and is low on charge.
R-22 is no longer produced, so recharging keeps getting more expensive.
Try the $5,000 rule
Multiply the system's age by the repair quote. If the result is over $5,000, replacement is worth pricing out. If it's under, repair is usually the better value.
Example: a 13-year-old system with a $150 capacitor failure (13 × $150 = $1,950) is usually worth fixing. An 11-year-old system with a $2,400 coil (11 × $2,400 = $26,400) usually isn't.
12 years × $600 = $7,200
Over $5,000: replacement deserves a look.
A rule of thumb, not a quote. Our technicians walk you through both options.
How we think about repair or replace
Age
Florida systems run far more hours a year than systems up north. Many reach the end of their useful life somewhere in the 10 to 15 year range, and sooner near salt water.
Which part failed
Capacitors, contactors and drain lines are cheap and routine. Compressors and evaporator coils are the expensive end of the list. See compressor repair vs. replacement cost.
Repair history
A second major repair within a couple of years is a pattern, not bad luck.
Refrigerant
R-22 systems are the hardest case. New systems are moving to R-454B. See what the R-454B change means for you.
Comfort and bills
If the house never feels dry, or summer bills keep climbing, a correctly sized high-efficiency system can fix problems a repair can't. Our SEER savings calculator estimates the difference.
Leaks, refrigerant and salt air
A refrigerant leak is the repair most likely to change the answer. Topping off refrigerant without fixing the leak just delays the next call. Coil leaks are common in coastal homes, where salt air corrodes the fins and tubing over time.
What a visit costs, and how we decide
We diagnose first, then give you the repair price before any work. If replacement is worth considering, you also get a free written estimate for a new system, so you can compare both side by side. No overtime fees on evenings or weekends. For typical repair numbers, see our AC repair cost guide.
Already have a quote? Get a free second opinion before you sign.
Frequently asked questions
Repair today, or plan a replacement? HVAC repair in Bradenton · AC replacement · Financing options
